Neither were wrong yet neither was right. Then of course the principal just told everythi I had a very large mixture of feelings about this book. Then of course the principal just told everything in a way that it favored him. Another interesting thing was how this one tiny occurrence spread into something larger than it was through media.
I also thought it was cool how this book was told mainly through conversation. May 28, Rob rated it really liked it Shelves: Nothing but the Truth is a subversive little Young Adult novel that takes on educational hypocrisy, personal accountability, and freedom of speech. Defying the school's rule of respectful silence during the morning playing of "The Star Spangled Banner," Phillip hums along, only to find himself suspended from school for Nothing but the Truth is a subversive little Young Adult novel that takes on educational hypocrisy, personal accountability, and freedom of speech.
Defying the school's rule of respectful silence during the morning playing of "The Star Spangled Banner," Phillip hums along, only to find himself suspended from school for disruptive behavior. What follows is a national firestorm, with Phillip being held aloft as a martyr for free speech, and his teacher, Miss Narwin, accused of anti-patriotism. Writer Avi weaves together multiple genres, incorporating memos, letters, interview transcripts, dialogue, and journal entries to provide the reader with a multi-faceted, Rashomon-like version of the story, and by the end, he has somehow managed to convince us that everyone involved in the scandal is simultaneously guilty and innocent.
It's a subtle, nuanced, sophisticated tale that doesn't have an easy — or clear — moral, and which gracefully and convincingly transcends its Young Adult label. Jan 02, Stacey B. I did not enjoy this book at all. The only reason I finished it was because it was short and a very quick read. The plot angered me and the story never really went anywhere. I just feel like more could have been done with the storyline. It was boring and nothing got accomplished. I do like the cover of the book. I love that it's simple and that they used the word to The Star Spangled Banner in the form of a flag; I think that's pretty clever.
Philip was an okay character. I understand that he is young and doesn't fully grasp the severity of the situation, but I feel like he could have spoke up at the end of the story. I did not like Philip's dad. It seems like this whole situation could have been avoided if Philip's dad did not push him so hard to talk to their neighbor when obviously Philip was reluctant to do so.
I also did not really enjoy the character of Miss Narwin. I feel like she should have tried a little harder to stand up for herself instead of just rolling over and taking it. Nov 22, Barbara Radisavljevic rated it it was amazing Shelves: The main character, Philip Mallory, is entering high school. He wants desperately to be on the track team, but he's not so interested in studying -- especially literature.
And he's not about to read The Call of the Wild. Philip has a habit that his homeroom teacher, Mr. Lunser, has tolerated in spite of the school directive that when the national The main character, Philip Mallory, is entering high school. Lunser, has tolerated in spite of the school directive that when the national anthem is played over the PA system, students will stand at respectful quiet attention.
Philip likes to hum along to it. Lunser has never made an issue of it. Lunser reminds me of some teachers I've had who like to joke around a lot. He makes jokes between the principal's Today in History comments that immediately precede the playing of the national anthem. Lunser actually talks to Phillip during the national anthem, telling him to put his book away. The book flips back and forth between the school directives as published,letters Philip's English teacher Miss Narwin writes to her sister, and conversations between Philip and his coach, Philip and his friends, and Philip and his teachers and parents.
The real thorn in Philip's side is Miss Narwin. He's sure she has it in for him because he doesn't do any work for her class. She is constantly trying to find a way to motivate him. She is conscientious, but she is compelled to give him a D in English. And then Philip finds out that will keep him from trying out for the track team. Then the homeroom classes all change teachers, and Philip winds up in Mrs.
the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth
Narwin is not anything like Mr. When Philip begins to hum to the national anthem instead of standing in respectful silence, she calls him on it and tells him to stop. They argue about it. Philip finally stops humming. When he goes home he tells his parents Mrs. Narwin would not let him sing the Star Spangled Banner, which he claimed to do from patriotic feeling. His parents say he should stand up for his right to express his patriotism in this way.
So the scene repeats itself the next day in homeroom, except Philip doesn't stop this time and Miss Narwin sends him to the principal. This happens again the next day, and over Mrs. Narwin's protest, the principal suspends Philip for two days, and his mother has to leave work to come get him. In the background you have school politics.
The Truth and Nothing but the Truth
The budget is inadequate, and an election is coming soon for a new school board and to vote on the budget. Teachers are being urged to talk up the need for the funds with their neighbors and others. Then Philip is suspended, as he explains it, because he sang along, or hummed, to the national anthem.
Philip's father's neighbor is running for the school board, and Mr. Mallory complains to him. This becomes an issue in the school board election. The newspaper reports on it. It gets onto the nationwide talk shows. Philip is transferred back to Mr.
- Sworn testimony.
- The Truth, the Whole Truth And Nothing But the Truth? Really?;
- Tutto casa (Bricolage e fai da te) (Italian Edition).
- The Tide Always Comes Back: And Other Irrefutable Truths and Assurances.
Lunser's homeroom and finally out of Mrs. Narwin is put on administrative leave. Administrators keep passing the buck. It becomes a national issue. The conflict appears to be that Miss Narwin believed Philip's humming was disrespectful and was out of line with the school rules about standing quietly at attention.
She considered his humming a disruption. Philip told his parents and everyone else he was humming from patriotic feeling. By the principal's admission, Miss Narwin is one of the school's best teachers, and we see from her letters to her sister that this is true, and she's trying to find a way to reach Philip.
When Miss Narwin is put on administrative leave for political reasons, even the coach and Philip's friends turn against him, because they all like Mrs. Philip's parents finally put him in a private school where they sing the national anthem every morning. And on Philip's first day there, when he's asked to lead it, he says he can't.
There was a problem providing the content you requested
And if you haven't read the book, I'm not going to tell you why. But you might want to read the book. The edition I have has study questions at the back which go pretty deep. But for those of you who have read the book, I have a question. Do you think Philip was humming from patriotic feeling?
Or was he trying to be disruptive? Nov 11, babyhippoface rated it liked it Shelves: I can't believe how much this book bothered me. I never have liked Avi much; I guess our styles clash. But I had heard about this title for years, so today I picked it up and starting reading. I don't yet know if I'm glad I did, or wish I hadn't.
The problem is that this scenario is more realistic than I would like to believe. In fact, an author's note at the beginning reveals that similar situations have taken place all over the country. And that is just So many characters o Wow. So many characters only looked at the events from one point of view, squashing the "truth" into the mold they preferred. Reaction without intelligent thought.
The major reason I disliked this book is that the main character, Philip, is an entirely self-centered, whiny, and unlikeable smart-alec who feels entitled and thinks he's funny when he's not. I don't understand why anyone who actually spoke to Philip himself would believe his version of the "truth". And that's the trouble--not enough people in authority actually speak to Philip. They don't read his body language or hear his snarky comments. They don't hear how his answers to questions change depending on the answer he thinks will keep him "in the clear".
Was he humming, or was he singing? He can't even keep that straight. Then those that do speak with him don't bother to speak to Miss Narwin about her motivation for sending Philip out of the room. They listen to what comes out of Philip's mouth and take that for the whole story. There are two characters who question the version of events they're being fed, though, a reporter and a radio caller: If only the other adults would have been struck with such common sense. It is never stated anywhere in the book that Philip has sung along with Star Spangled Banner before.
He does it in Miss Narwin's class solely as an attempt to get moved out of her classes. He baits Miss Narwin from Day 1, and the other students know it. Philip has no sense of "patriotism"--our first encounter with him shows him reading during the Anthem, and on the last page he admits he doesn't even know the words to the Anthem.
And yet he is hailed as a martyr for his patriotism by people ignorant of the facts. Made me wish there'd been a security camera rolling in the classroom, so the real truth could be revealed to everyone who felt so free to spew hatred to the teacher. I can see how this book could make for some mighty lively classroom discussions. Honestly, I really hated it.
But it is compelling, so it gets 4 stars on the "Interesting" scale. If Avi has gotten me this riled up I must have taken it just the way he intended. So, I'll slap 3 stars on it--and that's my version of "the truth".
- See a Problem??
- the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
- Nothing But the Truth.
Sep 28, Jayanni rated it it was amazing. Nothing But the Truth by Avi is a realistic fiction novel pointed at several characters, rules, or documents perspective. The author displays a stronger message than patriotism.
He shows through a realistic scenario how little lies can spiral out of control. In the book, Harrison High School plays a recorded tape of the national anthem each morning. It is requested that all students stand in silent and respectful attention. But when Philip Malloy decides to hum along in Ms Narwins homeroom, he r Nothing But the Truth by Avi is a realistic fiction novel pointed at several characters, rules, or documents perspective.
But when Philip Malloy decides to hum along in Ms Narwins homeroom, he receives a contradicting two day suspension. The author encourages the reader to explore the truth in his motives for getting kicked out; whether it was patriotism or a result from his hatred against the teacher. An interview from Philip Malloy was published, exploding the situation across the nation, ending in angry americans, economic damage towards the school, and personal difficulties for both Philip and Ms Narwin.
Personally, I enjoyed the book because of its format. Nothing But The Truth was written in a documentary form. I have to admit though, I got extremely frustrated when I witnessed how the story changed throughout each person's perspective because I knew it was purposefully.
The characters would not bluntly fib, but not reveal the whole truth. The author really displayed how individuals perspective of the truth can be used to their advantage. If you're a person who loves books with narration, Nothing But The Truth isn't for you. Although you can assume there's a main character, the story isn't told from that perspective. In fact, the book isn't told in just one, but multiple perspectives and scenarios. This book is also for readers who enjoy putting the pieces of the story together themselves.
Apr 24, Lara rated it it was amazing Shelves: Avi is one of my favorite writers. So this book is presented like a file for a crime. This even happened at this time and place. There is really no narration. Just a very stark, neutral telling of events. A young boy refuses to stand for the national anthem or refuses to say the Pledge of Allegiance or something like that it's been awhile.
The school wants to discipline him. He claims he has the right to not do it.
The Truth and Nothing but the Truth | HuffPost
But as the facts come to light, you see that the boy's defense m Avi is one of my favorite writers. But as the facts come to light, you see that the boy's defense may be a bit fabricated. It's really, really interesting. More of the way the story is told. I had to read this book for summer reading. I heard from others who read it before that it is really, really bad and confusing.
This was the only book that the teachers had for us, so I started reading it. This book really bored me and I hated how the poor teacher had to resign because of one student who just kept on exaggerating and partly lying to make other people dislike her. I feel that this is just a waste of my time reading and for other students to read. Nov 09, Rebecca rated it really liked it. This was such a great, though provoking book. I read it right before the election, which seemed appropriate. It just goes to show how easily the truth can get twisted.
It's a sad story, but I am still thinking about it. I can't wait to discuss it with someone. It just goes to show why I love children's literature. Oct 12, Jackson rated it did not like it. Feb 08, Ryan rated it it was amazing Shelves: I have loved this book since it first arrived in my Alaskan classroom via a Scholastic Book Order.
The year was , and this was hot off the presses. I had to have it. While I was always a reader, Avi made me fall in love with reading. It brought adventure, love, laughter. So much so I have loved this book since it first arrived in my Alaskan classroom via a Scholastic Book Order. This book is about patriotism and the right to sing the national anthem in school.
It has so much more between the pages. This is at least my fourth reading of this book. I have read it with my kids book clubs twice. I have also had parents try to ban the reading of this book for being to political for children to handle. Event today 27 years later it is relevant. Now as an adult I can see the sliding of history and the changing way we see things. Both from a childhood to an adulthood read, and a societal change.
There was this cartoon in some newspaper or journal that I wish I would have kept. In both frames there is a classroom, a teacher, a student, and a set of parents. In frame one the parents are standing behind the teacher talking to the child about what is going on at school and that things better shape up. In frame two, which is supposed to represent a new generation, the parents are standing behind the child and placing the blame on the teacher for bad grades,discipline problems, or whatever was happening. I was raised this way.
Get in trouble in school, get it twice as bad at home. To me Nothing But The Truth shows how far back this switch between ideologies begins. A lot further back then I would have thought. Is it Miss Narwin? Is it the parents? Is it the lack of money at the school. So much to talk about. So much that is still true today. Schools still do not have enough money.
People rally around news media stories that may only have one side. What is fake news. There are parts of this book that ages the story. But what would change today. Instead of a teleram, it would play out on social media. Maybe there would be Go Fund Me accounts set up for the parents, or the teacher to fight their side of the fight. The story and the themes found in this book are what make it current today. Without know how truely futuristic he was, Avi was writing a story of importance that resonates.
If I was ever again to run into literally Avi in Wash Park true story , I would love to pick his brain. How would he update his novel. How would he see this story 27 years later. Would he want to think about a modernization, or would it be just too depressing. Luckily for the current generation of kids, Avi continues to write. He continues to spin tales tall and outrageous. Tales from history, that make you want to know more. And tales that will become classics that you are ecstatic to share and pass on for generations.
Aug 02, Phil Jensen rated it really liked it. This is exactly how things go down- a student is uncomfortable about their academic performance, so they manufacture a fight about something unrelated. The next thing you know, the parents are screaming at administrators and you get called into the office to apologize to the family.
It feels unfair, but "it's unfair" is the wrong lesson to take from this story. At some point in my 16 years of teaching, I learned that reading students and communicating proactively are essential survival skills. It is part of my job to call a student's parents when they get less than a C in my class.
It is part of my job to call home if a student seems upset about my class. If I expect the school administrators to represent my perspective when talking to parents, then I will probably be disappointed. People only know what you tell them, so the parents are going to assume I'm insane unless I speak directly to them. Never engage in a battle of wills in front of a full classroom. Problem solve in the hallway or between classes. The more experience I get, the less eager I am to force students to read a particular book, no matter how good it is.
This book should be required reading for anyone earning a Bachelor's in Education. Nov 14, Madi Licious rated it did not like it. Ok so heres my review. It seriously was the shittiest book I have ever read. I would rather read the twilight series 3 times then read this shit again. The commitment can come in different forms depending on the situation of the witness. The types of commitment used in the United Kingdom are:. I solemnly and sincerely declare and affirm that the evidence I shall give will be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. In the UK, you can give testimony at any age, but will not be sworn in unless 14 years old or over.
Swear may be replaced with "affirm", and either "so help you God" or "under pains and penalties of perjury" may be used; all oaths and affirmations are considered to be equivalent before the law. Ward , the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that certain other modifications of the oath were acceptable so long as they demonstrated "a moral or ethical sense of right and wrong".
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Where did we get our oath?